A protein tub is a convenient way to provide extra nutrition when needed. One of its key benefits is that once you place it in the pasture, you can rest assured that you don’t need to check it daily. This benefit is beneficial for those who may have a job back in town, providing a sense of relief from daily checking responsibilities.
A benefit for both the full-time and “part-time” rancher is that a protein tub can improve the overall grazing in a pasture. You can move them into more underutilized areas to encourage cattle to move to those areas.
When making any type of investment, it is prudent to do your homework before making any decision. So, before you run off to the local feed store, I have five things you can look at before you buy your first protein tub.
Step #1: Do I even need a protein tub?
This question may seem like a pretty “duh” question to most of us, but some people out there do not even consider if they need it before buying one. So before dropping a nice chunk of change, you must figure out if a protein tub is even required.
An excellent way to determine if supplements are needed is to do a forage analysis. This analysis will tell you what types of nutrients and in what quantities your forages are providing.
Another factor you should consider is the overall quality of your forages. Here in Texas, we have been dry for most of the year, so using a protein tub is necessary. So, along with forage analysis, looking at your sheer amount is another good idea.
Understanding your cattle’s nutritional needs is crucial. The stage of production your cattle are in will determine what they need. For instance, a cow in late gestation will have completely different needs than a dry one. This knowledge is vital to making an informed decision about using protein tubs.
Once you have all of this information, it is time to do some math work. You will take what is being provided and what the nutritional needs are; if there is a deficit, then you will need to provide a supplement.
Step#2: What does the protein cost per lb.
One key aspect to consider is the cost-effectiveness of protein tubs. While one product may seem more expensive, when you break it down to a cost per unit of what you need, it can turn out to be a more economical choice.
A formula you can use to determine this is like what I used in a previous post, “What is that Hay bale worth?”. I will use the formula to determine the cost per unit of protein, but you can use it to find other things.
A benefit of protein tubs is that they are very low in moisture due to their manufacturing, so you won’t necessarily have to find out what the unit per dry matter is. A formula that can be used is this:
Cost of the protein tub / % Protein= Cost per unit of protein
When you have the numbers from the formula, you can more accurately compare “apples to apples.”
Step#3: Where do the minerals come from?
The source of the minerals is also essential to consider when looking at protein tubs. Where the minerals come from will determine how well they will be absorbed when consumed.
A usual comparison that you will find is chelated vs. non-chelated minerals.
Chelated
- bound to a chelated agent, organic compounds, or amino acids
- typically tend to be more expensive
- and can be recognized by the terms “proteinate or amino acid chelate.”
- allow for better absorption and utilization
Non-chelated
- It can be identified by the terms “oxide,” “chloride,” or “sulfate.”
- tend to be a less expensive form (which makes it the most common choice with feed producers)
- Not as well absorbed as chelated, especially with animals under stressful conditions, the more common types of minerals that you will find
Step#4: Will the protein tub have IGR?
When considering the type of protein tub to use, it’s essential to understand the benefits of IGR. This acronym stands for the Insect Growth Regulator, which controls flies around your cattle. By stressing the importance of IGR, the audience feels more informed about its benefits and its role in cattle health.
When the cattle consume the supplement with this additive, it doesn’t affect them in any way, so they pass it along in the manure. While it is there, flies will place eggs in the feces, and as the larvae grow, the IGR chemical will prevent them from getting past a particular stage.
When it comes to using IGR in your protein tubs, timing is of the utmost importance. It is recommended to start feeding it 30 days before the emergence of the flies. The fly emergence is usually in early spring when the temperatures begin to get in the 60s. An example is here in Texas, usually in the middle of March.
Once you have started feeding this, you must keep feeding the IGR throughout the year. In order to be most effective, you will keep providing it till 30 days after the 1st frost of the year.
Step#5: What size protein tub do I need?
Now that you have done the “math homework” and have decided that you will need to use protein tubs for your place, you must determine how large of a tub you will need.
A lot depends on the number of cattle you supplement, and the size of the cattle also plays a role in this decision.
A general rule of thumb is that you must have one tub per 25 heads of cattle. This general rule is relatively easy and fast, but we must consider the consumption rates.
Another thing to look at is what kind of equipment you can use. Protein tubs range from around 40 lbs. up to 250 lbs. If you do not have a tractor or skid steer to move the tubs around, it may be better to go with the lighter ones (unless you want to ruin your back).
Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. And he actually bought me lunch since I found it for him smile Thus let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch!